No One is Free from Criticism

Ravikiran has a nice entry on Yazad’s blog about Nehru and IIT.

The point about most people is that because somebody benefitted from studying in the IIT, it is somehow the duty of the person not to criticize its creator, Chacha Nehru.
Why? Applying this analogy to Subrata Roy Sahara (read my yesterday’s post) who organized a mass wedding (Samuhik Vivah), can we say he is above reproach for having spent a whopping Rs.500 Crore on his son’s wedding?
Let’s give credit where it is due: Nehru did a good thing by establishing the IITs, but his other Socialist policies prevented the beneficiaries of the IIT education from prospering, or rendering their services in India honestly and efficiently. It’s like this: you give me a yoke to work the earth but tie both my hands, and then ask me to till the land. What do I do? Either you untie my hands, or I wait for an opportune moment and then escape from you.
The problem with people–like the one who reproached Ravi from criticizing Nehru–is that for some reason they put “leaders” or other “important people” on a pedestal and try to make it impossible to criticize them. Gandhi is another example. There was a time when nothing negative was to be said about Gandhi. I agree that he was a great man, a noble soul, and a patriot, but he had his flaws for he too, like us, was human. What made him stand tall was that he had managed to transcend several common weaknesses that most of us find difficult to overcome due mostly to lack of courage and conviction. For example, how many of us have the conviction and courage to say, “because millions of my countrymen don’t have enough to wear, I shall adopt a similar dress?” Does this sound stupid? It might. But for Gandhi, it held a deep significance and he adhered to it till his last breath.
On the same note, did his efforts at uniting Hindus and Muslims succeed? No. Isn’t it our duty to critically examine what went wrong? Does this criticism in any way diminish Gandhi’s greatness? No.
This unfortunately, is a lesson most people need to learn.

2 comments for “No One is Free from Criticism

  1. larissa
    August 12, 2009 at 5:57 AM

    I think that Gandhi’s success lay in the fact that he was a very determined man above all else. He is great because the movements he started were successful, and other movements such as the Civil Rights movement in the U..S. and in South Africa were inspired by him and those movements were also successful.
    When you read the biographies of great men you realize that people are mostly herd like and enjoy following–it just takes a man with immovable determination to move the herd–does not have to be a man of great intellect–that’s what Gandhi was to me–his greatest asset was his determination.
    When you read his biography you might be appalled–even Naipaul was appalled–he appeared like a weirdo to me with a lot of complexes–obsessed with food and sex(in the sense of purity)–upon reading his biography he certainly is no leader of mine–Do not mean to diminish his greatness in anyway but that is my opinion of him…

  2. Manish Modi
    May 25, 2006 at 1:10 AM

    AIR SAHARA IS A REALLY BAD AIRLINE I MUST SAY. THEY CLAIM OF INTERNATIONAL QUALITY OPERATIONS, BUT YOU GUYS ARE THE WORST. WORST THEN SOME OF THE EAST EUROPEAN AIRLINES I HAVE FLOWN. MY WIFE HAD NO ONE TO DIRECT PROPERLY AT HEATHROW AIRPORT ON 24TH MAY 2006. SHE WAS RUNNING FROM ONE TERMINAL TO ANOTHER. ALL THE PHONES WERE UNREACHABLE ON LONDON. JET PEOPLE, WHOM WE WERE SUPPOSED TO REPORT, WERE UNAWARE OF WHAT WAS HAPPENING AND WERE EXTREMELY RUDE. NOT A PERSON FROM AIR SAHARA WAS THERE TO TELL PASSENGERS AS TO WHAT TO DO.

    I WAS CHARGED 110 POUNDS FOR THE FLIGHT CHANGE. BUT WHAT DOES AIR SAHARA PAY ME FOR CHANGING THEIR FLIGHT AND ALL THE HARASSMENT CAUSED. WILL THEY PAY ME 110 POUNDS? NO THEY WON’T.

    I PROMISE YOU; I AND MY FAMILY WILL NEVER EVER FLY AIR SAHARA OR JET AIRWAYS IN OUR LIVES.

    I REGRET I EVER CALLED THESE TWO AIRLINES AS REALLY GOOD AIRLINES IN PAST.

    MANISH MODI

    19, HOLLAND ANNEX

    POLLOCK HALLS OF RESIDENCE

    EDINBURGH EH165AY

    UK

Leave a Comment