The Left is rightly obstinate about not allowing its sins to be discussed in Parliament. In true Mafiosi style, they reason that it is a "state subject," hence out of bounds.
After a meeting of four Left parties, the leaders maintained that the Nandigram issue was a "state law and order subject" which could not be discussed in Parliament as rules did not permit such matters to be raised.
One wonders whether the state is located outside India. The Left is convinced that it is. Its grand old Don had once declared that he’d cede from the Indian Union if the BJP ever came to power. The following statement reminds us of Bollywood gangster films:
Parliament functions according to rules. Whatever the rules permit, can be discussed. …Nandigram can be discussed in the West Bengal Assembly but not in Parliament.
In other words, yeh mera ilaake ka maamla hai wohi niptenge (this dispute belongs to my area, let’s deal with it there). The Opposition in West Bengal is "full of sound and fury signifying nothing." Latest tidings show the kind of treasure the CRPF has unearthed in Nandigram.
The CRPF personnel on Thursday recovered a large amount of arms and ammunition,including 76 detonators, from Sonachura in Nandigram. The arms recovered from a pond during a raid included 76 detonators, 15 rounds of ammunition, 25 kgs of explosives, some explosive devices and material for making country-made guns,…
Offstumped rightly calls for imposing President’s rule in West Bengal. Historically, President’s rule was imposed on other states to merely satisfy political whims.
Here’s a free tip to the Congress party: show your guts and impose President’s rule in West Bengal. The President is after all, one of your own. You are anyway preparing for mid-term polls. If the government falls tomorrow, you’ll reap handsomely in the mid-term polls for just this one act.
Tags: Commentary, Indian Politics, Society & Culture, War on Communism, Weblogs
On 11.15.07 Yossarin says:
Sandeep - One lesson we must learn from all of this is that unlike every other political outfit, the Left in India never accepts a mistake or goes on the defensive. They have to remain on the offensive and brazen it out. The reasons are obvious, if Buddha is made to resign they are in deep trouble in Bengal. Their in lies their vulnerability.
On 11.16.07 » Conspiracy of Silence on Nandigram’s Muslim Victims | Offstumped says:
[...] So what perverse logic did Yechury offer ? Nandigram was a state law and order subject [...]
On 11.16.07 Sandeep says:
Yossarin,
You are right. Ever since it found a voice in mainstream politics, the Left has consistently sabotaged every good that we ever hoped to achieve/planned. All in the name of the “suffering people,” of course. Looks like Nandigram will be their Waterloo but again, you can’t underestimate the Left.
On 11.16.07 Anonymous says:
Guys,
It’s time we expose NDTV. This channel has totally blacked out Nandigram and it’s obsession with Gujarat continues unabated.
It continues showing Gujarat in the negative (sometimes cleverly wrapped in documentaries like “Consumerism on rise in Gujarat” etc) and keeps up the ante.
Pranoy Roy and his team is on a mission. He surely has an agenda and to his credit has a very sleek presentation power to influence gullible viewers. We should call his bluff. We should have a focussed target and keep exposing NDTV at every possible opportunity.
NDTV may not be the most watched channel but it certainly exerts influencing powers over other media houses far disproportionate to it’s actual popularity.
My theory is that most media houses follow NDTV’s call.
In the documentary on Gujarat’s consumerism the commentator (in a shrewed husky and humble voice) started talking of stock market and malls and then expectedly shifted focus to Baroda Art student issue and Gujarat riots. The insinuation was the Gujaratis are by and large money-minded but at the same time very intolerant.
The underlying notion of Gujarati mind being inhuman in a sense is induced in the documentary in a clever manner.
At the cost of going into regionalism, i feel that since NDTV is pre-dominantly Bengali , it is jealous of Gujarati success. Now i know most people would not agree. But come to think of it, Bengal does not have anything to show for last 30 years in terms of progress, both economical and social.
On the other hand Gujarat has moved on and growing at a very rapid pace, outperforming other states and in fact a few South Asian giants.
It’s difficult for “intellectual” Bengali like Roy to digest this. Also Modi , true to his style, always “gave it back” to NDTV whenever they tried to mess with him.
Again this is something the narcissist Roy does not take lying. I have observed that NDTV has been in the fore front of portraying Gujarat negatively in last 5-6 years.
Others just follow them.
NDTV’s single point agenda needs to be exposed again and again till the time they know that people are aware.
The focus lights should shift firmly on NDTV.
Sandeep - your forum would have thousands of visitors if not more. Let us come with some ideas to bell the NDTV cat. It is important for all of us that Media houses like NDTV do not go unexposed.
Modi is going to loose elections inspite of what IBN survey says. The reason is the pathetic so called Hindu voter is going to assume that BJP his going to win and not come out on election day. He/She would be watching Saas Bahu series on TV instead of going out and voting. This exact middle class apathy let down Vajpayee in 2004.
NDTV will ensure after Modi’s loss that he is hounded to death. Their glee will know no bounds and they will be shouting from roof tops about victory of secularism over communalism.
I seriously feel that operation “EXPOSE-NDTV” should be started by some talented “H-vadi” and if not today atleast make it pay for what it has done in the long run.
Only question is how to go about it?
On 11.17.07 Kumar says:
>>Pranoy Roy and his team is on a mission
Pranoy Roy is related to Brinda Karat if I’m not mistaken.
Could be case of hiding the family dirty laundry, after all it affects their bottom line.
On 11.17.07 Niketan says:
Pranoy Roy is related to Brinda Karat if I’m not mistaken.
Could be case of hiding the family dirty laundry, after all it affects their bottom line.
Kumar
You are right. Prannoy Roy is Brinda Karats brother in law.His wife and Brinda Karat are sisters.
Anon
I am mot sure if NDTV is really Anti Gujarati or if Roy is really a Bengali intellectual. It is plainly family issues involved here as shown above and anyway Modi is the favorite whippping boy of the media. Anything anti-Modi is bound to bring the right patronage.
On 11.17.07 Niketan says:
Sandeep
Anon is right about NDTV’s bias. As mentioned earlier by somebody on your blog, we do need a right wing channel else the NDTV’s and IBN’s will brainwash the next generation
On 11.18.07 Archee says:
@Anonymous:
How do you explain the fact that the only right wing English newspaper in India is much more bong dominated than NDTV. I am talking about Pioneer, Chandan Mitra is a bong ain’t he, as are Kanchan Gupta and Swapan Dasgupta.
I remember NDTV’s post Godhra riot coverage, and I remember it being covered by Barkha Dutt (Punjabi Dutt not Bong) and Rajdeep Sardesai (again, not a bong).
I really loved this part of you comment, this is some deep insight:
“On the other hand Gujarat has moved on and growing at a very rapid pace, outperforming other states and in fact a few South Asian giants.”
I have also noticed that California is progressing at a extremely rapid rate outperforming … Mexico.
On 11.18.07 Archee says:
Pranoy Roy is related to Brinda Karat if I’m not mistaken.
India’s political Adams family.
On 11.18.07 Archee says:
They have to remain on the offensive and brazen it out.
There is a difference between CPM and BJP : most of the top CPM leaders are fanatics, they are actually committed to their cause,in contrast the BJP top leadership is full of rank political opportunists who will cheerfully stab their own comrades. Unlike Hajpayee, Jyoti Basu will not make moronic statements about Rajdharma, he will not embarrass his CM. In a time of crisis, the commies pause their infighting, huddle together, present a united front , in the BJP, the knives come out and old scores are settled.
On 12.29.07 » Indian Blogosphere in 2007 - An Offstumped Retrospective | Offstumped says:
[...] There were other defining moments too through 2007 that saw the blogs steal a march on the mainstream when the CIA Archives were released, the Tehelka expose and the Nandigram issue. [...]
On 12.29.07 Blogger News Network / Indian Blogosphere in 2007 - An Offstumped Retrospective says:
[...] There were other defining moments too through 2007 that saw the blogs steal a march on the mainstream when the CIA Archives were released, the Tehelka expose and the Nandigram issue. [...]